Asphalt Shingle Roof vs. Metal Roof: Prices, Pros and Cons!

Category Roofing

9 May 2024,

Off

Are you looking for sustainable and durable roofing? Whether you have an asphalt shingle roof that needs replacement or looking to upgrade your roof, you have come to the right place.

We can provide you all the information you need to decide on the best roof for your home.

The roof of your home is an investment as it protects you and your belongings. It can also increase the value of your property!

Is it better to install an asphalt shingle roof or a metal roof?

Read on to compare asphalt shingle roofing vs. metal roofing including their pros and cons and prices.

The Main Differences between Asphalt Shingle & Metal Roofing

Before deciding on an asphalt shingle roof or a metal roof installation, you should compare their pros and cons.

For many homeowners, price is also a critical factor. But before we delve deeper into the costs, let’s first compare the features side by side.

Below you will find the distinct differences between these 2 types of roofing.

Expected Lifespan

Asphalt shingles can last from 15 to 30 years but that depends on whether you have architectural or basic and how well you maintain your roof over time. An asphalt shingle roof may need replacement after 20 years or so.

Metal roofs can last for 50 to 70 years if properly installed and maintained.

Re-roofing cost

It is your investment so you should make it last as long as possible. This is especially true if you plan on living in your house for a long time. An asphalt shingle roof replacement in Ontario costs from $3 to $5 on average. If you choose premium shingles, it could cost twice that amount per square foot.

A residential metal roof in Ontario costs about $8 to $16 per square foot. Again, you will notice that a metal roof costs a little more than a standard asphalt shingle roof. But they do last 2 or 3 times longer.

Maintenance

Asphalt shingle roofs need regular maintenance and replacement. Metal roofs need minimal maintenance.

Increase in Property Value

Homes with metal roofing usually have up to 6% higher market value than similar houses with asphalt shingle roofs.

Energy & Insurance Savings

With skyrocketing energy costs, homeowners find all potential savings appealing. That is why many people choose energy-saving roofs to reduce energy costs. An eco-metal roof does not retain heat like tile, cement, or asphalt shingle roofs. You can save up to 15% on annual energy bills. With a fire-resistant metal roof, you can also reduce your home insurance premiums.

So which one is better for your home – an asphalt shingle roof or a metal roof? Compare quotes to save time and money using our short online form at no cost!

Asphalt Shingle Roofs: The Pros and Cons

If you are planning to fix your existing roof or replace it with a new one, asphalt shingle roofs would be one of your top choices.

But why choose asphalt shingle roofing? Here are the advantages and disadvantages to consider before making your decision.

The Pros of Asphalt Shingle Roofs

Ease of Installation

It is easy to install asphalt shingles compared to other types of roofs. They can even be installed over old asphalt shingles as long as the deck is still strong and only one layer is installed.

Affordability

Labor and materials for asphalt shingle roof installation are cheaper, making it an economical option for homeowners.

Durability

The life span of an asphalt shingle roof is from 10 to 15 years, on average. If the shingles are heavy, the life span increases. Warranties usually are longer for higher quality materials.

Wide variety of colours & styles

Asphalt shingles come in a wide variety of styles and colours. They can mimic other styles at a lower price. You also have choices for energy efficiency to lower heat absorption during summer.

The disadvantages of asphalt shingle roofing

Periodic maintenance

It can be simple to keep the roof clean but you also need to ensure that the flashing does not let water seep through. Shingles can get loose. Wood shingles have a higher risk for insects and are a fire risk.

Poor insulation

Ventilation in the attic is important and affects the lifespan of the roof. Other roofing materials have higher insulation benefits.

Shorter Replacement Cycle

Asphalt shingle roofs tend to need replacement after 15 years. Other roofing materials like metal have longer lifespans which can stretch from 50, 75, to 100 years.

Consider the pros and cons of asphalt shingle roofs before making your choice. From a short-term economic standpoint, asphalt shingle roofs are ideal. If you want long-term roofing solutions that give more value for your money, consider installing a metal roof for your home.

Are Asphalt Shingle Roofs really less expensive than metal roofs?

Most homeowners think that a metal roof is more expensive than an asphalt shingle roof. This is only true if you are thinking of the initial cash outlay. But the truth is that a metal roof costs about 40% less with just one asphalt shingle replacement cycle.

What does that mean? As mentioned earlier, you will need to replace an asphalt shingle roof, on average, after 15 years. But most homeowners don’t need to install a new metal roof because they can last for 50 years!

In most situations, a new metal roof can be installed on top of an old asphalt shingle roof. You can save money and avoid dealing with the mess. The old shingle roof can act as a vapor barrier while eliminating the cost of disposal.

Lastly, you can reduce your home’s carbon footprint and protect the environment with a metal roof installation.

How Much Does a Metal Roof Cost?

What is the price of a new metal roof installation? Expect to pay thousands of dollars, in truth. The final cost will depend on the material if aluminum or steel, the style of the roof, your location, and other factors.

Find out what other considerations to keep in mind when installing a new metal roof.

Metal Roof Prices vs. Asphalt Shingle Roof Prices

Traditional asphalt shingle roofs cost less to install but will need a replacement after about 15 years. Harsh climates and extreme weather have a big effect on the lifespan of a roof, along with the level of care you provide.

When you get a professional roof installation, you can be sure to have a durable and energy-efficient metal roof with just a little maintenance. Your metal roof can withstand fire, moisture, heat, harsh winds, termites, etc.

Type of Roof	Average Cost
Asphalt shingle roof installation	$10,000 – $12,000 for 10-15 years in Canadian climate
Cost of Asphalt Shingle roof over 50 years	$30,000 – $36,000++ if replaced 3 times
Metal roof installation cost	$13,000 – $15,000 for 40 to 50 years in Canadian climate
Metal roof installation cost over 50 years	$13,000 – $15,000 (without a replacement)

What other savings can you get from a metal roof?

As much as 25% in cooling and heating costs
Lower operating costs with minimum maintenance requirements
Lower labor costs with faster installation
Savings on demolition and disposal costs when you install a metal roof over an old roof
Lower home insurance premiums

Why choose Professional Installation for a Metal Roof

You may think installing a new roof DIY is a cheaper alternative. But in the long term, the lifespan of a metal roof depends on the quality of the installation. Improper roof installation can drastically shorten its lifespan and cause unnecessary repairs or early replacement.

If the roofing project is small, for instance, a shed, a DIY roofing project may be feasible. But for the home, a professional installation is your best option!

Serious damage from leaks, moisture issues, and even structural issues can arise if a roof is not properly installed. A homeowner can also suffer serious physical injuries from an accident or a fall during installation.

Steel or Aluminum Roofing

You should also think about whether to get an aluminum or steel roof. Galvanized steel provides protection from strong winds, fire, and moisture and is cheaper than aluminum.

Aluminum metal is lighter and is resistant to corrosion and seawater. It is suitable for areas along the coastline.

Avoid a poorly installed roof by choosing a reputable roofing contractor from Compare Home Quotes! Our partners offer superior-quality installation that gives you the best value for your money.

Compare reliable roofers in your area by requesting free quotes using our short online form!

FAQS on New Roof Installation & Their Prices

When Do I Need a Roof Replacement?

Usually, a homeowner must replace the roof if it is damaged. Depending on the type of roof, expect to need a roof replacement after 12 to 20 years. Some roofs can last longer, even a lifetime.

Can I just repair the roof instead of replacing it?

Minor issues may be repaired if the roof structure itself is still viable. Issues like a few missing shingles, or minor leaks can be repaired. If the roof is old and is past its lifespan, a roof replacement is necessary. Contact a professional roofer to inspect your roof and give you the best solution.

Do I need a complete roof replacement?

Most professional roofers recommend a roof replacement from the undercoating to the shingles as that gives a uniform appearance and allows a cyclical replacement. Even a partial roof replacement can cost a huge sum. From a financial perspective, it is best to do a total replacement rather than piece by piece. It can save you money in the long term.

How do I choose a roof estimate?

You will need to get several quotes to compare for your project. You can also interview different contractors to get all the information you need.

Compare at least 3 quotes. Be wary if one offer is too low as it may be for subpar materials or work without insurance. Aside from price, check on the contractor’s recent projects and choose a company with a solid reputation.

On the other hand, if one quote is significantly higher, it may be the best roofer in town or one that charges way too much.

Do roofers offer a warranty or guaranty?

Reputable roofing companies offer a warranty on the roof installation. It is best to get a warranty in writing.

How long does a typical roof replacement take to complete?

A new roof installation can take 2 to 3 days to complete, depending on the size of the roof. Some jobs may take a week to complete. The contractor would indicate the start date and date of completion on the job order or written quote.

Does home insurance cover a roof replacement?

You must check on your home insurance policy. If the damage was caused by unexpected incidents such as extreme weather conditions, make sure to photograph the damage and speak to your insurer. If the roof has reached its natural end of life, your policy may not cover the cost of replacement.

Do you recommend asphalt shingle roofs?

An asphalt shingle roof is among the most popular roof materials as it is easy to install, affordable, and easy to maintain. If you want a budget-friendly and durable roof, it is probably your best choice. It can last for 20 years with proper installation and care. If you are looking for longevity at a slightly higher price, you may want to consider a metal roof that can last for 50 years.

Local Roofers’ Quotes to Compare to Save on Roofing Costs

For roof repairs or quality roof installation, compare local and reputable roofers in our network to save money.

Our partners will be happy to send you no-obligation quotes to compare so you can find the best company for your roofing needs.

If you are unsure of the type of roof you want, speak to our partners to get more details on an asphalt shingle roof replacement or metal roof installation.

Just fill out the short online form below to connect with the top roofing contractors near you!

GET 3 QUOTES FROM CONTRACTORS FOR RENOVATION WORKS