The top water heaters (residential) for Montreal and Quebec
- Ecopeak 60 gallon water heater / SUPER CASCADE Model # 172EPS-3F8M
- Bradford White 60 Gallon Water Heater Model # M265R8DS
- GSW 60 gallon water heater Model # G680TDE-45 250
- John Wood 60-Gallon Water Heater Model # JW880TDE-45
- Rheem 60 Gallon Water Heater Model # 629889
- Bradford White 40-Gallon Water Heater Model # M-2-50T8DS
- John Wood 40 Gallon Propane Water Heater Model # 100279318
- GSW 40-Gallon Water Heaters Model # G650SDE-30-250
- Rheem 40-Gallon Water Heaters Model # 630144
*in no particular order
Click on the water heater models above to read more info about each of those products and make the best choice.
COLD WATER IS A THING OF THE PAST !
Has your water heater given up? It can come as a surprise, happening just when you are enjoying a shower and you suddenly get icy water. What is there to do other than to replace the your water heater as soon as possible?
Are you going to buy the first model you find that is within your budget? Is there a water heater that will last you for many, many years? You must find answers to various questions before you buy your water heater replacement in 2024:
- What price are you willing to pay?
- How long do you want it to last?
- Will you change your type of water heater? (from an electric water heater to a hybrid or natural gas model)
- Do you want to do the work yourself or will you hire a professional (a plumber) for the installation?
Give yourself this exercise before continuing … (this will serve as benchmarks later)
When you have answered these 4 major questions, you will likely choose a particular model. Will you be satisfied with this water heater? What performance will it offer? In this article, we will dissect all the aspects that influence (or should influence) your decision-making. Clarifying the advantages and disadvantages of each type of water heater is likely to make shopping easier.
The Office of Energy Efficiency tells us that 20% of Canadian households’ energy consumption is used to power water heaters. That is enormous ! Since you are already thinking of a replacement for your water heater at home, can you kill two birds with one stone and save on your energy bills? A few minutes of your time will be enough to recognize the solutions that are within your reach in 2024 in Quebec.
DON’T TRY TO SAVE MONEY BY PUTTING YOURSELF AT RISK !
Compare Home Quotes offers you the opportunity to speak with a professional plumber with a good reputation in your area (Quebec or Montreal). For the purchase, installation, repair or maintenance of a water heater, trust only specialists in the field. Many mistakes can occur in an amateur installation. Do not put your safety at risk; compare 3 quotes for free by filling-out the form below.
These 3 quotes will come from professional and highly-recommended plumbers.
What features do you look for in a water heater?
For starters, it’s important to know how to untangle tankless and tankless water heaters, identify electric, hybrid, natural gas, or propane models before you even tackle the capacity, color, or size of your next purchase.
What does with or without a tank mean for a water heater?
This metal cylinder found in a multitude of basements in Quebec is part of a water heater. Usually, these cylinders serve hot water for 4 to 8 people. We will now describe these cylinders of water heaters with tank in this text.
Here are the main differences between the two types.
WATER HEATER WITH TANK
This type of device is found in the majority of homes in Quebec. Water accumulates in this tank while elements maintain a preset temperature. As soon as you use some of this water, the tank fills- up automatically.
In the case of ambient cooling, the device will compensate by heating more. When a water heater with a tank is placed in a cold place, it consumes a lot more energy. These costs are important considerations.
When you choose this type of water heater, you opt for a more expensive energy solution, but the water heater is more economical. This makes it difficult for buyers to decide.
If you’re looking for this type of device, try a high-performance model to dramatically reduce your energy costs.
Refer to our list of the best water heaters below to guide you in you your final choice.
INSTANT WATER HEATER (WITHOUT TANK)
An instant water heater is generally as big as a suitcase and occupies only a very small space. It does not store hot water (therefore more economical) and meets hot water demand in your home.
It is more economical that water heaters with tank and saves around 30% in energy.
In the event of high demand for hot water, you will feel a difference right away. You will find this type of device running on electricity or gas, the latter more advantageous.
Tip from an Expert: If you decide to install a water heater without an electric tank, expect to pay an electrician to proceed with the installation. According to experts, this type of water heater is not reliable enough to be a viable solution.
However, if you are thinking of using one in your second home or cottage, this option is perfect since you do not have to wait for the tank to fill-up.
Remember to drain your tankless water heater annually!
Discover the major differences in the types of water heaters
Several types of water heaters are available in the market using various energy sources to make them work.
Will you choose an electric water heater, a natural gas water heater, a hybrid water heater or a propane water heater?
Check below for their major differences to help you choose the right one for you.
ELECTRIC WATER HEATER: Conventional
Electric water heater is the most popular in Canada because of its small size and ease of installation compared to other models. It requires very little maintenance and is generally inexpensive.
It does not need ventilation and remains an ecological solution since no fuel burns in its operation.
If the unit is in a cool place, you will experience heat loss. You will largely preserve heat by choosing a quality inner coating for the tank.
NATURAL GAS WATER HEATER: Works even without electricity
Daily use of a natural gas water heater will compensate for the price difference compared to other electrical appliances. Indeed, it is more expensive to buy, but its daily use makes it more economical due to reduced operating costs.
Its fully autonomous electric system distinguishes it from other models and is its main advantage. It does not stop working even in case of power failure! It has no filters to clean and is very easy to clean.
When a toxic gas is detected, automatic safety protection is activated. Make sure you have the right ducts to vent the gas to facilitate installation of the water heater.
Natural gas water heater will simplify your life greatly!
HYBRID WATER HEATER: For long-term savings
If you’re looking for long-term savings, the hybrid water heater will do that for you! More expensive than other models in the market, it uses very little energy, almost half as much as the typical electric models sold in the market.
The cost of a hybrid water heater is certainly substantial (often $1000 or more), but it is easily recovered in about two and a half years from your energy savings.
PROPANE WATER HEATER: Less Common but still an option
A propane water heater is not among the popular models. If you can not connect to the public gas network and are looking for energy efficiency from a natural gas water heater, this option is still possible.
After seeing all these advantages, determining the right choice among all these water heaters according to your needs is an easier decision. However, another distinction is needed. Remember that you will also have to decide between instantaneous water heaters or tanks.
Ecologically-friendly, instant water heaters are more expensive to buy.
Water heater capacity: Is it always better to get the biggest?
Opt for a tank that has a large water capacity (enough for your needs). The following comparative table shows the capacity of the appliances according to the type of water heater.
Note, however, that a model selected for its greater ability to supply hot water will automatically have a bigger impact on your utility bills!
| WATER CAPACITY BASED ON TYPE OF WATER HEATER | ||
|
# of People who live in the home |
WATER HEATER WITH NATURAL GAS | ELECTRIC WATER HEATER |
|
1 Adult |
90 liters | 50 liters |
|
2 People, including an adult and a child |
90 liters | 75 liters |
|
2 Adults |
90 liters | 135 liters |
|
3 people, including 2 adults and a child |
135 liters | 180 liters |
|
4 people, including 2 adults and 2 children |
180 liters | 225 liters |
|
In excess… |
225 liters or more | 290 liters or more |
The above table shows that a natural gas water heater requires fewer liters (except for a minimum number of people) than an electric water heater for the same number of people.
You can purchase a smaller capacity water heater that can supply hot water to more users.
How do you know if your water heater is energy efficient?
Many possibilities are available to you in terms of water heaters (solar, heat pump …) which complicates the selection process. EF (energy factor) is at the heart of all your research since it determines the savings that can be gained using the device.
A high rating (on the water heater) means significant energy savings. It defines the quality of buckling, insulation, housing, burner, etc. The EnergyGuide label identifies (on the product) the annual cost to operate it.
Let’s look at the most energy-efficient water heaters below.
The Thermodynamic or Geothermal Water Heater
This water heater transmits heat and air to the air and water. Despite its higher cost of installation, this device can save you a lot of money.
The Solar Water Heater
This type of heater can give you most savings in energy. Solar collectors installed on a lean surface in square meters take care of transferring to the water the energy of the sun collected.
Savings can sometimes be as much as 80% of your consumption (in water).
Unfortunately, this water heater is not recommended for Canadian winters so we will only deal with it briefly.
ON-DEMAND WATER HEATER (WITHOUT TANK)
Their durability is guaranteed. Some models last for as long as 20 years due to their recyclable and replaceable components, unlike tank water heaters.
You will even find hybrid models (the cream of the crop) that will also heat your home!
HYBRID WATER HEATER
Because of 50% reduction in costs compared to an electric model , hybrid water heaters rank at the top of the list in terms of efficiency.
The hybrid water heater produces more hot water per hour than its rivals and some devices offer flexible modes to suck in more water and save even more!
Some models have FE ratings of up to 2.5!
Understand the criteria when looking for a water heater
THE MAUFACTURER’S GUARANTEE
The warranty on leaks usually runs around 6 years for a standard model. If you observe a warranty beyond 8 or even 12 years, you know that you have quality in your hands.
The guarantee is transferred from one owner to another if you sell your home. Be sure to read the instruction manual before proceeding.
RATE OF RECOVERY OF WATER
This is the number of gallons (per hour) that are warmed up. You will see an inscription on the device.
THE SIZE OF THE WATER HEATER
Opt for the water heater of your choice if you have a large space to store it. However, if you have limited space, choose a tank water heater.
THE FLOW OF WATER REQUIRED
Refer to the table above for a water heater with tank. For a tankless water heater, plan (for a single person) about 3 gallons per minute (for a single unit that uses water at a time).
Add 3 gallons per minute for each additional appliance that requires water.
For 4 appliances that would work at the same time (sink, shower, washer and dishwasher for example), it would be advisable to choose a water heater with a water flow of at least 12 gallons per minute.
TYPE OF ENERGY USED
Should you choose natural gas or electricity? A hybrid model, maybe? We will explain the differences between each type of energy to guide you in making the best choice.
If your budget allows, a hybrid (high yield) model might do the trick.
THE ENERGY EFFICIENCY REPORT
Many users do not realize the importance of this factor yet, but you now know that it is a critical factor. Your monthly savings on your electricity bill will delight you and will quickly pay for the considerable financial investment you have made for your water heater.
All you need to do is shop around to compare prices and choose the right model.
Comparison of popular water heater prices in 2024: Giant, Rheem, Bradford White, GSW and John Wood brands
We asked the experts what they thought about water heaters available in the market. Below are the results of our survey.
STANDARD PRICES FOR ELECTRIC HEATERS IN 2024
|
Brand |
40-gallon capacity | 60-gallon capacity | Expert tips | Common Warranty Offered |
|
Giant |
$549.00
Model # 152STE-3F7M |
$689.00
Model # 152STE-3F7M |
Very good for its price. Not as durable as Rheem or John Wood. One of the plumbers has a Giant installed at his home. | 8 years on the tank and 5 years on the heating elements and on the thermostat. |
|
Rheem |
$749.00
Model # 629872 |
$999.00
Model # 629889 (63 gallons) |
Professional models are the best water heaters on the market. Plumbers almost never needed to fix them. | 9 years |
|
Bradford White (installation included) |
$800.00 to $1300
Model #M-2-50T8DS |
$1100.00 to $1400,00
Model #M-2-65R8DS |
Bradford White manufactures water heaters of good quality, but Rheem and John Wood seem more durable. | 6 years on tank leaks (possibility to extend to 10 years). |
|
GSW |
$779.00
Model # G650SDE-30 |
$999.00
Model # G680TDE-45 |
These water heaters are a good choice in the average range. | 9 years |
|
John Wood (installation included) |
$900.00 to 1300$
Model # E50TEM-38240 |
$1000.00 to 1500$
Model #E80TEM-45240 |
Very good (reliable) water heaters, but you will pay a slightly higher price initially. | 8 years on the tank and 6 years on the heating elements and on the thermostat. |
Based on the above table, John Wood and Rheem models have high quality ratings but other manufacturers provide very good appliances at modest prices.
Primary Differences between Giant, Rheem, Bradford White, GSW, and John Wood Water heaters
Giant Water Heaters
Giant, a manufacturer of water heaters of all sizes, uses the latest technologies to improve its products and the efficiency of these products.
Their GREENFOAM technology offers very high quality
protection to keep heat through an insulating foam.
The Defender Safety System ensures that fire never leaves the combustion chamber to avoid accidents.
Finally, the company also uses ECOPEAK, a technology that uses, not 2, but 3 elements that heat the tank water more efficiently.
Rheem Water Heaters
Rheem water heaters have the following characteristics:
- They are designed to provide, when requested, a rapid hot water supply.
- They have received CSA certification.
- An automatic thermostat and 2 elements of 3000 watts heat control of available water (in the tank).
- A 60-gallon tank is enough to provide a household of 5 to 6 people (or even more) with hot water.
- A 40-gallon tank is enough to provide hot water to a family of 2 to 4 people.
- The tank has an extended life.
- They meet and exceed the NRCan efficiency standards.
Expert Note:Rheem manufactures the most durable and efficient water heaters in the market. These devices have unsurpassed features. However, these products are not always advisable for everyone. You can spend more than triple the average price for a standard model.
The specialist said that Rheem water heaters rarely break.
Bradford White Water Heaters
Bradford White aims to constantly grow and invest in new technological developments.
They have put in place Vitraglas technology which protects the tank from corrosion with a special enamel.
They also invented Hydrojet, a technology that destroys
sediments and maintains the water temperature.
GSW Water Heaters
GSW greatly reduces heat loss by:
- Turbulator ™, a unique (patented) immersion tube
- Outstanding insulation
- Tank Saver ™, their proprietary and patented technology that prevents corrosion and seals weld seams (connections) with washer-shaped protectors.
- Styropor®, an expandable polystyrene insulation on the base of the tank.
Sediments (their formation and accumulation) in a tank are the primary cause of damage in a water heater. Thanks to the immersion tube, the limescale particles remain in circulation in the water of the tank instead of settling down and causing problems. Strong turbulence in the bottom of the tank resists them while the exit of water then expels them.
This process significantly increases the energy efficiency of GSW electric water heaters.
John Wood Water Heaters
John Wood water heaters do not just meet NRCan’s energy efficiency standards, they exceed them. These (norms) change from province to province, but John Wood has always been able to adapt to them and propose models that adapt to the requirements of each region.
John Wood uses this powerful Styropour® insulation at the base of their water heaters for increased energy efficiency. Their (residential) electric water heaters use Tank Saver technology. This new technological feature extends the life of the electric water heater tank by protecting the joints from corrosion. An enamelled protective layer also covers the (inner) wall of the tank to prevent the spread of rust.
How to prepare the installation of a water heater
It is strongly recommended that you use the services of an expert for the installation of your water heater. A single oversight could be disastrous. A certified plumber will provide a warranty in case of breakage for his work. In addition, if you calculate all the materials to buy for installation, you will quickly realize that the bill is very similar to a professional doing the job.
Do not leave anything to chance! Even one of your multi-talented acquaintances can make a mistake and cause expensive water damage. Hire a professional to install your water heater to avoid problems.
The Cost of DIY (Do It Yourself) Installation
To give you an idea of the cost associated with a DIY installation, here are some examples of the costs and the time required for this process.
| Expenses associated with the Installation of a Water Heater by an Individual | ||
| Procedure | Expense (Average Cost) | Length of Time |
|
The purchase of a water heater in a specialized store |
$700 * |
20 minutes at the store. |
|
The purchase of materials to proceed with the installation |
$150 |
45 minutes at the hardware store + the time needed to return home with these materials. |
|
Delivery of the water heater |
$50.00 |
Most specialty stores can have your water heater delivered within 24 hours. |
|
Actual Installation |
$180.00 |
4 hours. |
|
Grand Total |
$1080.00 |
About a day of waiting + an investment of 5 hours of work on your part. |
*This represents the average price for a water heater (40 to 60 gallons).
The prices displayed here are only estimates. Many homeowners with apartment buildings do business with a plumber for the installation of water heaters. The plumber offers an efficient service at a good price, and the entire installation process usually takes less than an hour.
If you want an outstanding and professional service to acquire a quality water heater, use Compare Home Quotes network to find the best device at the right price. Fill-out our form (which does not commit you to anything) below to compare prices.
Let our partner plumbing experts advise you properly on the purchase of your next water heater. They will provide you with tailored proposals (based on your needs) in order to help you save money.
This service is very fast and free.
Where should you install your water heater?
Save yourself anxiety by following the following basic tips:
- Install the water heater close to the bathroom to maximize performance.
- Your floor should be as level as possible for greater stability.
- Your electrical box must be nearby.
- Be sure to place it near your floor drain to simplify the process.
- Refrain from positioning your tank water heater in a cool place. It will cause the loss of too much heat as well. Rather, opt for a warmer room.
What procedures do you need to follow to install an electric water heater?
There is no law that requires you to hire a certified plumber. However, we strongly recommend that you do to avoid risks. If you have the necessary knowledge and skills, below are steps for replacing a water heater yourself:
- Turn off the power to avoid problems.
- Stop the water (close the inlet valve).
- Purge the (hot) water from the tank.
- Remove the hoses (some will need to be unscrewed with a wrench).
- Extend the tank.
- Shut off the cold water inlet (do not cut the hose too much).
- Grab a “T” fitting to the pipe and attach it to the water heater tank (the new one).
- An opening will be created. Attach another hose so that the valve can stop the water if there is a breakage situation.
- To avoid spills, always plan for emergencies.
- Check if the seals are waterproof.
- Inspect the valves and the (hot) water tap.
- Complete the electrical junctions.
Tips regarding maintenance and prevention: Extend the life of a water heater
Some checks can easily be put in place to increase the life of your water heater.
- If the internal thermostat stops working, replace it easily at the corner hardware.
- Drain the tank on an annual basis to remove sediment that accumulates over time.
- Remove the inner walls of your device.
- Test the safety valve occasionally. If it no longer blocks the water, replace it.
- Replace the sacrificial anode if it no longer prevents tank corrosion.
- Remember to check the proper functioning of the two elements that heat your water. Their replacement is cheap.
Note from the Expert:To prolong the life (and do not forget to mention it to your insurance company) of your water heater, check the titanium anode of Corro-Protec, which adapts to all types of appliances . This protection system stops corrosion that may occur in your hot water tank. A 20-year warranty will add a few years to your water heater!
If your insurance company is Desjardins or Le Capital, you will get a pleasant surprise!
A unique service that will save you a lot: Group installation service
Compare Home Quotes provides a discount if you opt for the group set-up service. Our experts will go to your area only once so that everyone can save time and money.
The top 10 water heaters (residential) for Montreal and Quebec
Here is the list of the 10 best water heaters in the market in Quebec.
Be prepared when you change your water heater: save on time and the cost of the appliance.
Despite all these tips, if you still have some doubts about how to choose your next water heater, do not worry.
The partners of Compare Home Quotes, experts in the field of plumbing, will give you their best advice and solutions via our short online form below.
This free and no obligation service will provide you with up to 3 quality quotes to find the water heater you need. Enter your selection criteria in the relevant fields and you will receive prompt answers from our carefully selected water heater specialists.
PREPARE TO GET GREAT SAVINGS!
| We would like to acknowledge the assistance of specialists from these reliable companies who specialize in the installation of water heaters. | |
 |
Water Heater Expert |
 |
Plumbing Expert |
